355 Haley Scott Dr, Union Hall
(540) 529-4294
Red Key Realty
Contentment Island is one of Union Hall's most popular upscale lake communities, with large waterfront homes on streets like Lake Shore Drive, Pine Bay Drive and Westridge Lane. The Cottages at Contentment Island add townhomes on Summerwind Drive for buyers who want less upkeep.
In the past two years, about 11 homes have sold at Contentment Island and The Cottages, with asking prices from about $900,000 to $3.2 million and an average near $1.57 million. Homes average about four bedrooms and 4,000 square feet. Any homes for sale now are listed below. Figures come from live MLS data as of November 2026, change daily and are rounded.
Get a free home valuation or contact The Lee Team at (540) 529-4294.
Back to Union Hall lake homes or the Smith Mountain Lake waterfront guide.
Get instant property value now!
Get instant property value now!